Play Live Radio
Next Up:
Available On Air Stations

How A 2011 Tornado Outbreak Changed One Of Alabama's Top Weathermen


There's a lot meteorologists understand about weather forecasting, but there's even more they don't. They face uncertainty every single day, and when it comes to severe weather, how they navigate that uncertainty matters. It can get people killed, or it can save lives.

In 2011, one of the deadliest tornado outbreaks on record tore through over a dozen states, hitting Alabama the hardest. Today Abby Wendle from NPR's Invisibilia brings us a story about how that 2011 outbreak changed one of Alabama's top weathermen.

ABBY WENDLE, BYLINE: Weather forecasting is tough, and tornadoes are perhaps the trickiest to predict. There's no way to know exactly when one will touch down or where or what direction it will go - towards trees or people. Up against all these unknowns, James Spann, one of Alabama's top TV weathermen, lives in a permanent training exercise.


WENDLE: 4:52 a.m. - alarm goes off.

JAMES SPANN: This is cut No. 2 in five, four, three, two, one.

WENDLE: 5 a.m. - record radio weather spots.

SPANN: Mostly clear weather continues tonight. We'll forecast the low at - (clearing throat).

WENDLE: By 9, James is off to teach severe weather preparedness.

SPANN: The No. 1 reason people died that day is this, the siren mentality.

WENDLE: 2:30 p.m. - head to the studio for the 4, 5, 6 and 10 o'clock news. You can find James Spann bobble heads and T-shirts. In Alabama, he's basically beloved. And the feeling's mutual.

SPANN: These are my people, and I just feel a responsibility to take care of them.

WENDLE: Now, he's also gotten his fair share of criticism, especially about one thing.


SPANN: My position is this. The climate is changing. The climate has always changed. The climate always will change.

WENDLE: This is James in a 2018 VICE interview.


SPANN: The question is, what is man's role?

WENDLE: That paints him outside something scientists in this century have been most sure of - man's starring role in climate change. But when it comes to Alabama weather, he mostly gets it right. So in the last week of April 2011, when he started seeing signs that the weather could turn really bad...

SPANN: This could be a very significant tornado day.

WENDLE: James did what he does, prepared - first the TV station...

SPANN: No. 1, we had to get our weather staff straight.

WENDLE: ...And then the public, warning them over and over again for two days straight.

SPANN: Be around a radio. Be around a television. Be around a radio. Be around a television.


SPANN: Around a television, radio, television, radio, television, radio.


SPANN: We got reports of debris falling out of the sky.


WENDLE: At the TV studio, James was live.

SPANN: The radar was lighting up like a Christmas tree.


SPANN: Tornado No. 1, tornado No. 2, tornado No. 3...

WENDLE: Some were huge, with winds whipping faster than a race car.


SPANN: Get into a safe place right now.

WENDLE: And then one was on top of the city of Tuscaloosa, ripping apart schools and churches and houses.

SPANN: You were looking at pure, raw, graphic violence.


SPANN: Goodness gracious.

WENDLE: James, the master of uncertainty, found himself struggling to keep it together.


SPANN: This will be a day that will go down in state history, and all you can do is pray for those people.

WENDLE: April 27, 2011, 62 tornadoes touched down in Alabama on that day. Numbers vary, but about 250 people died.

KAREN: He dealt with it for a year.

WENDLE: This is James's wife, Karen.

KAREN: He didn't really want to talk about it at all, did you?

SPANN: It was about months.

KAREN: Six months. I just remember that one morning at the kitchen table that he broke down and cried. That has never happened in our marriage. He does not cry, and it really gravely concerned me.

WENDLE: Nobody was supposed to die on his watch.

SPANN: This is insane. We've got to find out what happened and fix it.

WENDLE: James grew obsessive, certain there had to be an answer. So he holed up in his office and watched the tapes of his live coverage from that day over and over and over.


SPANN: Goodness gracious.

What happened here? What just happened?


SPANN: This is a very serious situation.

What went wrong?

WENDLE: But it's not just James. This need for the answer is a problem for all of us.

JAMIE HOLMES: We have this need for closure, a need for answers, a need for order.

WENDLE: This is science writer Jamie Holmes, author of "Nonsense: The Power Of Not Knowing." He interviewed dozens of psychologists who told him that when we face an uncertainty that's threatening, we become desperate to end the uncertainty. In his book, Jamie catalogs a series of experiments by psychologists Travis Proulx and Daniel Randalls. In one experiment, the researchers had people read Kafka.

HOLMES: I love Kafka.

WENDLE: Then Proulx and Randalls showed them long strings of letters...

...Like A-B-C-D or like...

HOLMES: Exactly.

WENDLE: ...Z-F-G-D...

HOLMES: Exactly.

WENDLE: In one letter subset, there were patterns. In another subset, there weren't. But...

HOLMES: In either case, those who read this surreal story from Kafka identified more patterns when there weren't patterns and even when there were patterns.

WENDLE: Reading the surreal story kicked people's need for things to make sense into overdrive.

HOLMES: It's sort of like, do you see Jesus in the burnt toast, right?


In multiple experiments, researchers have found that when we are exposed to an unexpected dose of uncertainty or an uncertainty that is particularly threatening, we become desperate to end the uncertainty, which can lead us to jump to conclusions instead of making rational decisions.

HOLMES: Sometimes the solution to uncertainty is knowing that you can't control it. You can't predict it completely - ever. And so you have to stay in it and stay in it without panicking.


SPANN: OK. And again, I want to be sure people listening and watching understand. You are watching a large tornado that approaching...

I'd be back in my little closet back there and kind of shut the door and just let it run.

WENDLE: Day after day, James sat with his footage, sat in the discomfort of not understanding, the hunger for certainty tugging at him to figure it out, find an answer. Any explanation will do. But the more he searched through the footage...

SPANN: You know, I just went through it and listened to what I said and...

WENDLE: ...And watched...

SPANN: ...Watched the video elements we had and...

WENDLE: ...And looked and listened...

SPANN: ...Trying to sort out in my mind what was good and what was bad.

WENDLE: The more James began to realize...

SPANN: It was very confusing. I didn't have a good answer for that. I don't know.

WENDLE: The most certain man in the world embraced uncertainty, let go.

SPANN: You're brought down to your knees. Maybe everything that we've thought was right is wrong. Maybe we're living life upside down. I don't know.

WENDLE: And when he did, the answer he was expecting to find, the - it was me, I failed in front of the green screen - seemed too small to hold the tragedy of April 27.

SPANN: You don't have the time or the energy or the brainpower to save everybody, doesn't work that way. You're not some superhero. You're just a stinking weather guy on television.

WENDLE: James didn't have firm answers, but for the first time since the storms had hit, he had something maybe even more valuable - a mind open to new information. Abby Wendle, NPR. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.

Abby Wendle